My point of view on the main characters.
The main character of the story, its central is Ms. Emily Grierson. To my mind, she is quite a controversial figure. Though the author blatantly strived to underline her high level of self-dignity and honor, I still feel rather a pity to her. She was an insane lunatic and in the contemporary society, a psychiatrist could have helped her. Emily 1) desperately refused to let go of her past; 2) she was a control –freak; 3) she was unable and unwilling to adjust to the society, to fit into its rules and follow its directions.
1)Emily couldn’t except that the
Colonel Sartoris is not alive (when the new authorities come to ask her to pay
taxes) and also refused to give the dead body of her father to burial.
2) Her father didn’t allow any of the
man to marry her , i.e. he controlled her private life severely and thoroughly.
When her father died, Emily tried to take controlled over the Homer Barron.
She, obviously, wanted finally to marry somebody, and she liked the man – but
he wasn’t really inclined to marriage. Moreover, I suppose that her company
didn’t make him much delight, for Barron was cheerful and lively. I also
suppose that their “time perception schemes” didn’t coincide. He was “a
diminishing road” living in the moment, and she was a “huge meadow” immersed in
the bygone days.
3) To my opinion, she did her best to
circumscribe herself from society – and that was her huge mistake. Everybody
and women in particularly need socialization and communication.
Now about a
few things I find attractive in the heroine. She had her own rules in life and
had never violated them – Emily cared but little of what others said or
thought. She was assertive to refuse to pay taxes, to refuse to state the
reason for buying poison and to have numbers attached to her house. That is why
the society cared for her – not in the traditional meaning of the word, but she
just attracted their attention, she was out-of-the-cast, eccentric and
grotesque. They never understood her, claimed to feel pity for her destiny,
but, actually, never it was nothing more than curiosity and fear. The Baptist
minister who had called upon her never ever divulged what happened in her
house, but he would never ever visit her house again. And drug-man didn’t come
out with the poison himself – he asked the negro to deliver it.
“Just as if a man - any man – could keep a
kitchen properly”, the ladies said. – this quote from the text exemplifies that
women condemned her, her way of life.
"Being left alone, and a pauper, she had become
humanized. Now she too would know the old thrill and the old despair of a penny
more or less." – People wanted Emily to be like
them, to feel what they do, as they couldn’t understand her motives.
So the next day we all said “ She will kill
herself” and we said it would be the best thing. – can we talk about any sympathetic attitude
considering that people thought it OK for her to kill herself?
"Then some of the ladies began to say it was a
disgrace to the town and a bad example to the young people." – Another example of condemnation
and slander. She was just a theme to talk about in a little town, where
inhabitants had no interests of their own not to intrude in other people’s
lives.
She had
dignity and did not show off her weaknesses, her steel hair reminds me of the
idiom “the iron lady” – that is whom she was.
To sum it
up, my verdict would severely contradict critics on the Internet and opinions
of the colleges of mine. Emily is hardly a positive character and I failed to
detect anything that could have served the reader as an example or an
inspiration for his/her own life. Let’s face it – she was weak and feeble.
Emily had all the opportunities to be happy, but didn’t endeavor to make them
work out. OK, her father was strict and severe, but could you show me somebody
who doesn’t encounter obstacles and face hardships in life? Shouldn’t they
stiffen one’s will and temper one’s character? Positive attitude, optimism,
work and a good deal of efforts make everything possible, isn’t it?
Homer Barron is a foreman from the North, paving
sidewalks and renovating the town. Contrary to Emily, he is “change”,
“movement”, “facility”. Emily can be described as “stableness”, “weight”,
“standing still”. Homer Barron possesses charm, good sense of humor and is
always a center of attention. Nevertheless, people consider him not a good
match for Emily, as he is socially of lover status.
Their Sunday drives become scandalous. The author tells us, that Homer is “not
a marrying man”, i.e. he is hardly going to marry Emily – he is an eternal
bachelor, fond of carouses with other men. Anyway, he arouses in me more affection, than
Ms. Emily does. She is rather apt to arouse sympathy and pity.
Комментариев нет:
Отправить комментарий